Rockstar wins in Strip Club Trademark Case
WARNING
We are currently in the process of moving servers, due to this some of RockstarWatch may not appear as it should. We have managed to place a partly working version of the website on the new server, that is what you are currently viewing. Before the server move we were working on a huge overhaul and update to the website, for the time being this has been placed on hiatus until we complete our server move and configuration. However, rest assured the new and highly improved version of RockstarWatch is just around the corner!

Kind regards,
Jared & Aj

11
Nov
Rockstar wins in Strip Club Trademark Case

Published November 11th, 2008 at 5:55 PM PST | Posted by Jared | Added to Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas »

Recently, a real-life strip club named PlayPen in East Los Angeles took Rockstar to court over the fictional strip club in GTA: San Andreas, The Pig Pen. The PlayPen believe that the strip club in the game, located in East Los Santos, violates their trademark on the "PlayPen" logo.

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed the claim last Thursday stating that Rockstar did not violate the PlayPen Gentleman's Club logo. Rockstar did admit that they were inspired by the real-life strip club, hint the fact it is located in the same place in game as it is in real-life. They also argued that that they are protected under the First Amendment.

Judge Diarmuid O'Scannlain's ruling was probably one of the best I have ever heard:

"Video games and strip clubs do not go together like a horse and carriage or, perish the thought, love and marriage."

Honestly, suggesting a strip clubs name and logo used in a parodic manner in a game violates the trademarks of the real-life counterpart is a rather far-fetched reason to take a gaming company to court.

Source: MercuryNews